Lavish simchas

YOUR correspondent Martin Stern’s comments about lavish simchas are disingenuous.

Families who hold them are often exceptionally generous long-term donors to charities and communal causes.

Moreover, if a very wealthy family held an “austerity” barmitzvah or batmitzvah, then you could be sure that someone — maybe even Mr Stern himself — would criticise them for publicly embarrassing their children by not spending as much as they could obviously afford to mark their special day.

No letter from Mr Stern would be complete without his tilting at the Reform windmill and this time he castigates them for (horror of horrors) allowing the celebration of a girl’s coming-of-age to be “held back for a whole year” to coincide with her twin brother’s barmitzvah.

But in most communities — certainly Orthodox ones — a boy attains barmitzvah on the day after his 13th birthday without the need for any ceremony or even shul attendance.

The same applies to a girl, who becomes batmitzvah the day after her 12th birthday.

Ceremonies, celebrations, parties, speeches and presents are modern, secular and optional extras with no prescribed time.

In any case, Mr Stern must surely be aware that delaying festivities is commonplace in Orthodox communities if the bar or batmitzvah falls during the counting of the Omer, when hearing music is forbidden, while for a family of more limited means — or in cases when guests travel from afar — it would surely make sense to hold a single party for two siblings rather than two separate ones.

Herbert Goldberg,
54 Wakehams Hill,

E-MAIL: letters@jewishtelegraph.com
Full names and addresses must accompany letters and will be published unless correspondents specify otherwise.

If you have a story or an issue you want us to cover, let us know - in complete confidence - by contacting newsdesk@jewishtelegraph.com, 0161-741 2631 or via Facebook / Twitter

Publication of all letters is subject to our terms for submission of works to us (past and present), namely that, if your letter is used:
1. Letters may be edited in the interests of space. Please restrict your letter to 200 words.
2. Anonymity will be in exceptional circumstances and at editor’s discretion.
3. A daytime telephone number is also necessary for checking the authenticity of your letter.
4. The Jewish Telegraph and those authorised by it have the world-wide assignable right to use your work in any publication or service in whatever media (e.g. CD Rom, newspapers, online etc).
5. The Jewish Telegraph may further allow others to store/distribute your letter.
Data Protection Act: your name and address is collected for the limited purpose of validating correspondence by the Jewish Telegraph.

Site developed & maintained by
© 2018 Jewish Telegraph